Strange Peas in a Pod: Sharon Stone and John Hagee

Mick Turner

The recent comments by Sharon Stone regarding the Dalai Lama, Karma, and the earthquake in China has got my dander up just a tad. If you are familiar with this blog, you know that I have a strong affection for and connection with the Chinese people. I served on the mission field over there for five-plus years; my wife is Chinese; and we have family and friends all over China.

In case you didn’t hear her brick-headed comments, actress Sharon Stone suggested that the suffering caused by the recent earthquake in Sichuan Province was the result of “karma”, gleaned from the fact that the Chinese government “has not been nice to my friend the Dalai Lama.” Good Grief!!!!

What Ms. Stone fails to understand is that, even if one subscribes to the notion of karma, it doesn’t work quite the way she states it. First of all, it is the Chinese government, not the Chinese people who have a problem with the Dalai Lama and the whole Tibetan issue. The central government didn’t suffer so much as a result of the disaster, but the Chinese people surely did. At last count, over 69,000 dead and the toll is still rising. Also, in her myopic vision, Ms. Stone also fails to realize that, outside of Tibet, the largest population of Tibetans in China is in the mountain areas of Sichuan, the very epicenter of the earthquake. I dare say that there were quite a few Tibetans in those 69,000.

In the wake of her comments, the people of China are in an uproar. Movie theaters in China now refuse to carry her movies, and she has I think three or four new releases coming out over the next two years. So now, Ms. Stone will not profit from the largest population of movie goers in the world. Now that, my friends, is karma!

Stone’s comments are similar to those made by John Hagee on the heels of Hurricane Katrina. Hagee said that the disaster was a result of God’s wrath over an upcoming parade celebrating homosexuality. I find it ironic that Jesus, who Hagee says is his Lord, stated that “if you have seen me you have seen the Father.” Hmmmm. Let’s see, I don’t recall Jesus unleashing a hurricane on the woman caught in adultry or the Samaritan woman at the well. No, he exhibited a God of grace, not a God of retribution.

Do you see the similarities between Stone and Hagee? Both are suggesting that these disasters came about as a result of some sort of cosmic retribution. In Hagee’s case, it was God who was miffed. In the case of Stone, it was an impersonal but equally nasty force at work.

In either case, I am saddened by these comments. It is a shame, really it is.


3 thoughts on “Strange Peas in a Pod: Sharon Stone and John Hagee

  1. cer

    I’m saddened that you didn’t listen to, or understand her full comment. She ASKS whether it may be karma, but then tells how she comes to the opposite conclusion. No one is actually listening to her. She doesn’t say it was karma. Watch the whole thing again. I’m not saying she’s a brain surgeon, and of course she comes across as a ditz, but she didn’t actually do what you said she did. This is trial by media, in the interest of Chinese hegemony. Think about it.

    karma in chinese, btw, is a collocation that means “causal retribution”. it doesn’t carry the specific, religious connotations of the word “karma”. this might just be a stupid translation error.

  2. Mick Turner

    I have listened to the whole thing five times now, I don’t think I could disagree with you more. Her comments, in totality, show not only her ignorance of the China/Tibet conflict, but of Buddhism as well. I should think in these situations, if one lacks knowledge and has a public voice, that voice should remain silent. If she had kept her mouth shut, there would be no “trial by media” or anything else.

    As for the Chinese, in everyday usage, especially among Mainland Chinese, karma carries direct religious connotation. Only in academic circles has it been “sanitized.” As for Chinese hegemony, please, give me a break. They didn’t start this. Think about it!

  3. Pingback: Dear Kitty. Some blog :: Sharon Stone, John Hagee, and other anti-scientific nonsense :: May :: 2008

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s